Suitcase Killer: The Melanie McGuire Story Reviews

She totally did it.

Such a bad movie lol I couldn’t stop watching

Amazing!

👍🏻🏆

Terrible acting

It was a interesting story, but nothing to write home about the portrayal of it…

Was okay.....

Very very very hallmarky but Candace ate

Not a meh but not a like. Could tell it was a lifetime movie

it was ok

7/10

I hated this movie so much.

She did it

She definitely did it

Like the case coverage but not a fan of lifetime acting.

I’ll kick things off by saying this is definitely one of my least favorite Lifetime movies so far…

Candice King was a pretty solid pick for the role of Melanie, even if it’s a bit strange to see her with dark hair—it actually suited her character well.

I went into this movie without any prior knowledge of the story, and I was genuinely taken aback by what unfolded. I would’ve put money on the idea that Melanie was hiding in the suitcases.

Two things can be true at the same time: Bill was a cheating, angry, gambling addict who mistreated his wife, while Melanie came off as an egotistical, self-absorbed, possibly sociopathic individual who chose murder over getting a divorce. I’m still unsure how closely this movie mirrors the real-life events and people, but it definitely had that classic Lifetime vibe!

*As always, my rating/review is based on a Lifetime scale, which differs from the standard movie ratings.

I was a little skeptical because it was a lifetime movie, but it was pretty good. I think she got a raw deal though because there is no way that the prosecution made their case.. I’m surprised the defense didn’t call the ex-girlfriend to atttest to his violent temper?

Has massive potential but it just seemed a little amateur. The tone didn’t quite fit the plot, needed to be way darker. Quite disappointing

6.5/10

Candice is a great actor, couldn’t get through the first 10 minutes