The Manhattan Alien Abduction Reviews

Started fine, but then just turned into two Karen’s bickering with each other.

Hmm not a fan. Almost considered shutting it off but figured I could get through 3 episodes. I didn’t like the way the documentary was done. It was a she said she said between 2 women. And kind of about aliens.

DNF

This is a pretty crazy documentary. Part 3 really brings it all home.

A documentary with an interesting stylistic flair - posing itself as a face off (of sorts) between a supposed experiencer and a skeptic. But it felt like a lot was missing here. It really needed an objective point of view, otherwise it’s just two people telling stories.

Interesting-ish, would’ve liked to see more witness interviews and expert testimony

x

i really liked the two opposing views this presented, it really got by thinking!

I dislike anything with aliens so I was hesitant but… do I believe it was a hoax. Yes. 100% Espically after I found out about her short music career. She wanted fame. But it also left me wanting more. Hearing from witnesses. What is in her nose. Why won’t her son be shown?!

Very interesting!

First two episodes were solid but third was extremely biased - I can see why the main woman is suing Netflix now… I’m really tired of these documentaries that pretend to be objective by not having a narrative voice but it ends up having the opposite effect with extremely subjective editing and sequencing. Missed opportunity for Netflix to actually do some real investigation into a super interesting story/mystery….