Rated: 4.4/10
Seeing Anthony Hopkins play a paranoid King Herod in a Nativity drama got me to check this out on Netflix. I dislike it; turning the Nativity into a glossy YA action-romance drains the quiet humility right out of the story.
The Director's Eye (What Worked):
• Anthony Hopkins chews the scenery as a ruthless Herod, while Noa Cohen and Ido Tako try their best with the script.
• Gavin Struthers’ sunlit Moroccan landscapes and Chefchaouen streets look sharp on screen.
• Repurposing Ridley Scott temple sets gives Jerusalem real physical scale.
The Friction (What Didn't Click for Me):
• Having Joseph fight off a mob and Herod’s guards like an action hero feels out of place.
• Gabriel in a blue hoodie and Eamon Farren’s Lucifer lurking with worms feels like a CW fantasy show.
• Even after 74 script drafts, the dialogue sounds way too modern.
The Verdict:
I dislike it. Watch for Hopkins acting and the Moroccan sets. Skip if you want a grounded Nativity story.
2d
It’s not historic and not even good fiction just a bunch of bullshit it’s such a waste of time and only a select few of the actors actually fit their role🤦🏻♀️
1y
ulianaastg loved
Mary
Watched it with my mom it’s actually good but not really following the religion
1y
Jana disliked
Mary
It’s not even good fiction. If you want people to feel any sense of realism, historical or otherwise, don’t have a weird mix of accents, or imply there were somehow dozens of babies born in “O Little Town of Bethlehem” all at the same time.
So ridiculous. 🤣
1y
Jen liked
Mary
This is a very fictionalized version of the story but as long as you go in understanding that it’s a well done movie about Mary and the birth of Jesus.
1y
𝒯 liked
Mary
I’m not religious, so I didn’t mind the dramatized take or the inaccuracies. I mainly watched it for Eamon Farren — great choice for Lucifer, even though he had very little screen time. The costumes and cinematography were visually pleasing, and the acting was solid.
1y
Eye Cinc liked
Mary
Sober, to the point without all the mumbo jumbo in the scriptures. It’s interesting and once again Anthony Hopkins it’s great.
1y