CPops disliked
Lanterns
WTF DC, I don’t even understand. This is butchery of a beloved property of the DC universe. I’m tired and I can’t comprehend it anymore. DC is on a non stop mission to destroy itself. Snynder cut wasn’t perfect, but at least it represented the green lantern core competencies.
84d
ant loved
Lanterns
I’ve never read or seen any other green lantern media so not sure what I expected from this show but it was better in a lot of ways and worse in very few. the cast is great, dialogue was always great, and the story itself was pretty interesting as a mystery. the back and forth between hal and john definitely carried the show for me but there there some other cool things too. hoping to see more action in season 2 or beyond for sure but i’m happy enough with everything I got from this
42d
Victor K liked
Lanterns
The writing is what shines the most here from its witty and engaging dialogue to its grounded characters. Depending on your mileage your enjoyment of this series might be dependent on the reveal of its central mystery. At times I’m unsure if the show adequately develops and…
37d
GoatLord is "meh" on
Lanterns
6/10
I have mixed feeling about this show, on one hand it does have decent writing, great casting, and honestly top tier casting. But on the other hand, the show feels incredibly low budget and seems to either be completely clueless regarding the source material, or just not caring to do it justice.
The show also is weird in the sense that it is a superhero show, kind of, but it doesnt seem to want to be. There is very little action, powers are barely ever used, and most of the focus is more on the drama and mystery among the characters. That's fine and all, but I expected a green lantern show, not The Boys.
Oh yea, the show seems to heavily want to mimic The boys in its tone. The show has a very dark and gritty tone, with little censorship, I'm talking uncensored gore and full nudity. This surprised me since James Gunn seems to wanna steer the DCU away from DC's previous dark and gritty tone, and into a more funny and goofy family friendly tone (Similar to the MCU).
38d
Cyclical liked
Lanterns
Green Lantern is one of those characters that I’ve just never really been exposed to. Beyond a pretty bad John Stewart animated film I watched a few years ago, I have never seen any movies or read any comics or really been exposed to either of these characters. So, when a slow-paced, True Detective-inspired grounded murder mystery drenched in Americana was announced… it’s definitely not what I associate with Green Lantern, but I was ready for anything. And, because I didn’t go in with any real expectations, I was totally blown away.
First of all, I just have to give credit to Kyle Chandler and Aaron Pierre, because their performances are what make this show work so well. This show’s success is entirely based on the dynamic between Hal Jordan and John Stewart, and both actors portray such deep, interesting, charismatic characters. Aaron Pierre plays a John Stewart heavily burdened by a difficult upbringing, and he does such a good job of bringing that gravity to the role. But, holy shit, Kyle Chandler is just incredible in this role. He is so funny and charismatic, but also brings such a deep-seated pain to the role that I really didn’t expect. These are probably my two favorite performances in the DCU so far (though David Corenswet, John Cena, and Nicholas Hoult are up there too).
I also just love the tone of this show as well. Because it takes place in such a small town with a dark mystery at its heart, the show is able to establish a really isolated, oppressive atmosphere that feels actively hostile to our protagonists. It also just gives us so much interesting lore about the Green Lantern Corps and the cosmic state of the DCU as a whole, and I can’t wait to see where they take it from here.
However, this show is absolutely not perfect, and I see where a lot of the complaints about it are coming from. From the standpoint of writing and characterization, they knocked it out of the park. It was able to stay grounded and restrain itself in a genre that is currently so obsessed with team-ups and cameos and CGI. I honestly think that is one of the show’s greatest strengths, but it is one of its primary weaknesses for a lot of people, and I can’t really disagree with that. For people that love Green Lantern and its mythos, there is so much we simply didn’t get here. This show is entirely about two guys walking around in Rushville, Nebraska, and that is where it stays. We don’t really get any space-faring or cool constructs or flying around, and it is really easy to question where that $100 million+ budget actually went. Since I don’t know shit about Green Lantern and just wanted to be taken on this ride, it landed great for me. But, for a lot of people that love the characters, I can see why it’s frustrating.
I’ve seen people defend the show from these points by saying that next season or the future of the DCU is what it’s all building towards, and while that may be true, I think that’s a bad way of looking at it. We need to be able to judge a season of television on its own merits rather than where it might be headed, as it’s all we have for now. It also doesn’t help that this show did a toooon of that “tell, don’t show” mentality where we hear about a lot of crazy stuff, but none of it actually happens on-screen. Even as a viewer that doesn’t care about how closely this show is tied to what is expected from a Green Lantern property, it was pretty frustrating to have all this information dangled over our heads without actually being able to see it. Television is a visual medium, after all.
Overall, though, I was blown away by this show. Seeing this sort of thing tells me that, despite some faltering with Supergirl, the DCU is still absolutely headed in the right direction, and I can’t wait to see when these characters pop up again. But, even on its own merits, I am just so happy to see such a grounded, emotional, personal story being told in a universe that is so much larger than life.
39d
Charles Haubein loved
Lanterns
So damn good. Characters are good, humor is good, plot is interesting. Ending was good but not great, excited to see what they decide go do going forward. Banger show
40d
Spencer loved
Lanterns
The DCU is in safe hands 😮💨
Honestly, going in, I had kind of forgotten this show was coming out until episode 1 dropped. But by the end of the first episode I was locked in. The “True Detective” style with the rural midwest backdrop made for a killer setup, and mixing in Green Lanterns was the cherry on top. Aaron Pierre is awesome as John, and Kyle Chandler is absolutely perfect as Hal Jordan. Genuinely perfect castings for both main characters. I thought the writing was great all throughout, and the finale really tied up the emotional side of things nicely. Super stoked to see these characters in future projects and I would LOVE to have a season two for this show 🙏
Definitely recommend to any superhero fans, or anyone who’s a fan of a genuinely well-written show. Can’t wait for what’s next 👀
8.4/10
42d
Dutchie is "meh" on
Lanterns
there’s practically no green lantern stuff shown. i tuned in to see superheros.
42d
Rubie Kelly loved
Lanterns
Great show! Closer to the Watchmen TV show than the previous lantern installations. Really funny without being cheesy. Cool action scenes, no upsetting CGI, the camera shots kind of avoid anything thats going to be glaring. Actors are great too, likeable asshole & respectable cop
80d
Zoe liked
Lanterns
This could’ve been in the hall of fame if it had been 2 seasons. One whole season for the manhunter and then Noah gets his own so we can love and fear him. The truck scene wldv been Emmy worthy if we had that. The message of fear was rushed too and that’s john’s whole thing
30d
Thebluemonkey69 loved
Lanterns
This is so difficult for me because. As a show the first half is amazing and the last 3 are mediocre with exception of ep7, but it feels so spiteful to the source material in so many ways especially with how Hal is done which is a shame because he carries this show hard 8.7/10
42d
Angel is "meh" on
Lanterns
Was so invested, until episode 6-8. Got disappointed in the direction they went.
38d
Noah loved
Lanterns
This really was some PEAK tv. Primetime HBO 9pm does not miss. This might have been one of the best comic book tv shows, let alone a top tier show in general. The castings for both Hal and John are generational. Their dynamic throughout the show was perfect, and also having a slightly different chemistry with Hal then with Halogram. The mystery and the story was so intriguing, and the characters development was well done. The balance and interweaving of the flashbacks and different timelines were pretty much perfect.
42d