iCarly Reviews

This show is actually trash but Carly makes me feel better about myself so I guess it does it’s job… don’t watch high though, badddd ideaa

Okay, this show is WAY better then you think. It does get off to a rocky start, but by season 3 it gets soo bingeable. I love that they are still the same characters at heart, but have obviously matured in a hilarious way. I’ve rewatched this so many times and have had a blast.

the whole creddie thing messed it up.. besides the new characters were funny yea but i hated how they basically forgot the original icarly plotline

No thanks

Due to the controversy surrounding the makings of icarly I give this a dislike. The cast and actors are amazing but the producer should be banned from the industry.

I wish I could say that I liked it but it felt so forced. It was one of my favourite shows growing up and I really missed Sam in this. It just doesn’t feel the same anymore.. The new characters are insufferable, especially Millicent. I guess now it‘s over because it got cancelled

Carly my bitch fr

Deserves Season 4!!! So mad they canceled it!

IT CANT END LIKE THATTTTT

I NEED A SEASON 4 NOWWW

i watched this and hated it and then went back to it and loved it. honestly such a big part of growing up was nickelodeon for me and this show was it all

such a good comeback

Icarly was my fav show growing up. This new series is super funny

They could have done so much better 😭

yes

Overall not a bad reboot for iCarly, obviously woudl’ve been nice if there a few more episodes and if Sam was in it but it’s understandabke why she’s not. I do think the cliffhanger at the end does leave a bad taste in my mouth but hopefully that gets resolved with the movie they were hoping to have done which apparently starts production this year (2026).

Other than that, it made me laugh, made me cringe, and was an easy binge in the big ‘26 so it was enjoyable. Carly and Spencer were amazing as always!

Solid 7/10 🔥

Really enjoyed the reboot - even though you could definitely feel the absence of Sam. Wish it hadn’t gotten cancelled 😞

pretty good

Incredibly cringey but I don’t think it would be icarly without it lol

Really good show. I used to watch it a lot when I was younger. It’s definitely corny but extremely entertaining and funny.