A History of Violence
2005
·
Movie
·
96 min
·
Drama
·
Thriller
·
Crime
85%
Community
5,098
LOVE
15%
LIKE
70%
MEH
12%
DISLIKE
3%
Queue Score
Top Reviews
Ellis is "meh" on
A History of Violence
Why is everyone in the reviews saying this is good I’m so confused, the acting is like one tier above porn acting and more so the plot is just kinda stupid. The characters are all boring as hell. Like it felt like they were doing a parody of nuclear family characters for the wife and kids. They were so nothing burger. Also why was it 6 bucks to rent this movie nottttt doing that. I went into it blind just cause it’s a cronenberg and I really thought it was gonna be about the two guys at the beginning cause I feel like that would have been a way more interesting movie than this shit. Like the family is so boring so you don’t care about Joey like winning, and the other guys aren’t fleshed out enough (before they die) so it’s not like you lowkey want them to win. And I don’t mean that in a “i can’t root for the mc if he’s a bad guy way” I mean like he was so boring I could not gaf way. Make him eviler??? Eastern promises mogs this movie so hard. I kinda think cronenberg was going for a similar vibe with the two of them and either he perfected (or at least greatly improved) it with eastern promises, or the script and actors were just wayyyy better. Yk this movie feels like. It’s like a weird bad short story that like ur uncle wrote or like you find it on the printer in a public library. I can’t really explain that but I’m right.
280d
RayRay disliked
A History of Violence
Should’ve been a porno, not a Hollywood production—multiple extended, pointless sex scenes. Terrible dialogue, bad acting, ridiculous music and nonsensical plot points. 90% of scenes lacked any purpose whatsoever. The bullying was hysterical, feel like I got pranked—so bad.
235d
Recent Reviews
Thomas Joyce liked
A History of Violence
Such a methodical slow burn, even at 90 mins, the film isn’t afraid to take things slower.
To call this an “action film” is inaccurate, even with several seriously brutal action sequences, it feels fr more akin to a character drama - just that this character is ex-mob! The lingering and framing of scenes is so effective here, there’s a lot in the theme of duality, watching the curtain fall in moments between the “front” and who Tom really is, is so well done - even just a slight altering of lighting does wonders in showing “a new light”.
Viggo Mortensen is terrific, it’s no secret - I think he’s always excelled at the more quiet characters who are in touch with normality. Playing both ends of the spectrum is no easy feat, but of course he achieves it effortlessly. Ed Harris shines with a small screen time, ditto for William Hurt who manages to be really quite funny, even in a dire circumstance.
I’m not too well versed in Cronenberg’s filmography, but this still feels like a shining example of what he can achieve amongst his other weird and wonderful pieces of work. On a side note, the Criterion remaster looks terrific if you were ever debating picking the release up!
8d
Kane Smith disliked
A History of Violence
No idea how this has so many positive ratings.
It stinks. Bad writing (there's a reason you've never heard of any of the writers other work).
Awful acting throughout.
unnecessary bush.
And yet this was an Oscar nominated film... no clue.
Absolutely pointless experience.
4/10
77d