Widow's Bay Reviews

so good! great blend of suspense/horror & comedy. if you’re unsure of the show I would suggest keep watching and never drink the punch!

There’s nothing much happening 6/10

Meant to rate this a while ago but Peak Apple TV ready for season 2
8.7/10

So far so good! When it opened up it gave me Jaws vibes, I liked the setting and using the island as the main source of all of the supernatural stuff going on in this show. I really liked how it took different aspects of the horror genre. Still can’t believe how funny it is. Such a good balance

when i started watching it i was worried it wouldn't be good because i would compare it to From, but it was completely its own thing, and very different from every other horror show or movie i've ever watched. now i want to watch more stuff with Matthew Rhys.

Dude… this shit was a BANGER. It was so fucking funny i didnt expect to laugh that much but the delivery from the actors was j too good. All of the cast was amazing, they were just so unique. The finale was perfect, and i honestly have zero complaints, just ready for next szn😸

I NEED SEASON TWO RIGHT NOWWWWWW

I loved everything about it.
I highly recommend everyone to watch it without hesitation.

best show of 2026.
super underrated

SOOO GOOD and way too underrated 🔥
Literally the perfect combination of horror and comedy and the acting and plot was genuinely amazing.

9.3/10 🔥🔥

very pleasantly surprised by this. i had no idea what to expect but it turned out to be one of the best coastal town thrillers (with a side of comedy) i’ve seen in a while. as someone said, it’s midnight mass’ twin. the twist ending was also good and how it’s left open

Its painful and boring to watch.

Winner 6 awards at Emmys award 2026 you gotta watch it.Funny and lots of mystery
8.5/10

Cannot recommend this enough, I’ve been preaching the gospel of widow’s bay to anyone and everyone. Perfect blend of comedy and horror

HAVENT EVEN FINISHED IT BUT THIS SHOW IS SOOOO PEAKKKKK. I LOVE PATRICIA. PATRICIA MY QUEEN.

Very interesting

good plane watch. jk it’s actually kinda bad. JK it’s actually kinda good! took a while to get there for me but it’s Campppp

subscribed to apple tv for this show & im so glad i did. literally such a good show , patricia is my spirit animal and episode 4 is my favoriteee, i wish we saw more scenes w/ dale though

This was so great! Definitely fun during fall🧡

Surprisingly good and refreshing